Home | About HV | Top Ten Lists | Newsletters | Events of Interest | Links


2006 Top Ten Endangered Sites

 

This year marks publication of the sixth annual Heritage Vancouver Top Ten Endangered Sites. Since its inception, our "Top Ten" list has been recognized as the authoritative overview of the city's threatened heritage resources.

It is, sadly, always difficult to keep the list to ten: the explosive real-estate development market exerts constant pressure on our heritage stock. That designated heritage sites are on our list is cause for great concern, and we continue to be anxious about the state of the Heritage Register. The final choice of sites include those already in critical danger or likely to be so shortly.

Back this year in the No. 1 spot is the Burrard Bridge, threatened yet again by the new City Council's decision to scrap the proposed lane-reallocation trial and proceed full-tilt with sidewalk outriggers. Arthur Erickson's Evergreen Building is not yet out of the woods and remains on the list. Back on the list from 2004 is Malkin Bowl, as TUTS continues to raise funds to replace it. Predictably, a host of new sites are endangered, including Salsbury Gardens, the Vogue Theatre, and the iconic 2400 Motel on Kingsway.

 

 

1. Burrard Bridge (1932) (updated)
Hatchet job. These are the only words to describe the current plan to widen the bridge's sidewalks, as the newly elected City Council wasted no time overturning the previous Council’s trial-lane reallocation.
> see full details

 

 

2. St. Paul's Hospital (1913 & 1931/1936)
1081 Burrard Street
One of the landmarks of downtown Vancouver, the venerable red-brick St. Paul’s Hospital built on Burrard Street, may soon be just a memory. Political questions swirl around the issue of whether or not the hospital should be moved — from its original site in downtown Vancouver — to a completely different location in the False Creek Flats.
> see full details

 

 

3. Evergreen Building (1980) (Saved - updated)
1285 West Pender St.
The future is still uncertain for this modern landmark. Arthur Erickson designed the Evergreen as an office building for owner John Laxton. Completed in 1980, the Evergreen’s unique stepped terraces and hanging gardens were configured to create the experience of working on a mountainside.
> see full details

 

 

4. Vogue Theatre (1940)
918 Granville St.
Say it’s not true! Vancouver's fabulous Vogue theatre — a National Historic Site and a Vancouver Heritage Register A-listed site — is threatened. Allied Properties has purchased the building, and the initial plan to convert the theatre to a supper club/cabaret suggests an irrevocable compromise of the theatre’s elaborate interior spaces. Stepped tables may replace the theatre seating with the existing stage converted to kitchen space.
> see full details

 

 

5. The "2400 Motel" (1946) (Updated)
2400 Kingsway
The future of the 2400 Motel — Kingsway's iconic landmark — may soon be up for public discussion. Rumour has it that the City will soon be conducting a planning process for the stretch of Kingsway around the '2400' with a view to encouraging higher density residential/commercial developments. In fact, the City has already been working with the owners of the nearby Eldorado Motel to rezone and redevelop this site as a mixed-use development.
> see full details

 

 

6. Salsbury Garden (1907) (Lost - updated)
This unique site, known in the neighbourhood as “Salsbury Garden”, comprises three city lots at the southwest corner of Napier St. and Salsbury Drive, including two historic BC Mills cottages (#1117 & #1121) and an extraordinary heritage garden/forest. The two small working-class homes, built in 1907, were probably the first houses built on this part of Salsbury Drive and are rare surviving examples of early pre-fabricated construction.
> see full details

 

 

7. "Black Swan Records" Commerical Kits Building (circa 1922) (Lost w/ some parts salvaged - updated)
2936 West 4th Avenue
Old Kitsilano — particularly its early 20th Century commercial buildings — is rapidly disappearing. The former ‘Black Swan Records’ building — a cherished community landmark at the corner of West Fourth and Bayswater — is set to become another casualty of unabated condo development.
> see full details

 

 

8. Malkin Bowl (1934) (Updated)
Stanley Park
On a return engagement from our 2004 Top Ten list, Malkin Bowl remains in serious danger as TUTS (Theatre Under the Stars) organizers continue to raise funds for its demolition and replacement. ‘Marion Malkin Memorial Bowl’ was built in 1934 with funds donated by William Harold Malkin, grocery wholesaler, former Mayor, and Park Board Commissioner, in memory of his wife Marion Malkin. Originally designed as a band shell, the venue has been used for most of its history for the summer TUTS musicals.
> see full details

 

 

9. Stewardship: City-Owned Heritage Sites:
Hastings Mill Store Museum (1865);
Roedde House Museum (1893);
City Hall Windows (1936)

The 1865 Hastings Mill Store Museum, Vancouver's oldest building, could be endangered through long-term neglect. Sole existing survivor of the Great Fire of 1886, the building was once the company store for Hastings Mill — located on Burrard Inlet at the foot of Dunlevy Street.
> see full details

 

 

10. Kogawa House (1913) (Saved - updated)
1450 West 64th Avenue
In late fall 2005, City Council approved a 120-day demolition delay to allow sufficient funds to be raised for the purchase and preservation of the Kogawa House as a cultural and literary landmark. The Land Conservancy of BC (TLC) has stepped in to help raise the over one million dollars required to buy the house and pay for the repairs and renovations necessary to convert it to a writers’ centre. However, if efforts to purchase the property within the 120-day period (which ends March 31) are unsuccessful, the current private owner will demolish the house.
> see full details

 

 

> top of page